Every Darth Sidious Duel — and the Three He Never Drew

A hooded silhouette seen from behind standing in a dark hall, facing six faint pools of green and crimson light arranged in an arc

Darth Sidious ignites a blade six times in canon. He comes out ahead in five of them and loses one on blades, and the loss is the only one anybody remembers. Then he stops. Across three later confrontations, including the two that kill him, he never draws at all — and that gap between the swordsman and the man in the chair is the actual subject of this page.

Two names, one man. Darth Sidious is the Sith identity of Sheev Palpatine, and by the last day of the Clone Wars the public title is Emperor. This page uses Sidious for the fighter and Palpatine only when the office is the point.

Quick answer

  • Six canon duels, not five and not nine. Mandalore, Dathomir, his own office, Mace Windu, the Senate, and a lesson with Vader.
  • He loses exactly one on blades: Windu disarms him, and the film shows it plainly.
  • He draws two hilts once in his life, against Maul and Savage Opress on Mandalore.
  • One hilt shape, 19 cm, phrik body with an electrum finish, plus a near-identical backup.
  • Three confrontations with no blade: Luke on the second Death Star, Rey on Exegol, Ezra in the World Between Worlds.
  • Four fights people invent: Nihilus, Obi-Wan, Dooku and Plagueis never duel him.

The six duels at a glance

Ordered by when they happen. Mandalore and Dathomir are both Clone Wars-era, which puts them before the office fight everyone assumes is the beginning.

# Opponent Place His blades Blade result
1 Maul and Savage Opress Mandalore, Sundari palace (19 BBY) Two Wins. Savage dies, Maul is taken
2 Mother Talzin, in Dooku's body Dathomir (19 BBY) One Wins, with Dooku and Grievous
3 Kolar, Tiin and Fisto His office, Coruscant (19 BBY) One Wins in seconds
4 Mace Windu The same office, same scene (19 BBY) One Loses. Disarmed, then saved by Anakin
5 Yoda Galactic Senate rotunda, same night (19 BBY) One, the backup Blades end even; Yoda withdraws
6 Darth Vader The Works, Coruscant (early Empire) One Wins. It is a lesson, not a fight

Five of the six sit inside a single year, all of them before the Republic falls. The sixth comes just after the Empire is declared, and after it he does not draw again for twenty-three years.

What counts as a duel

The rule here: he ignites a blade himself, against an armed opponent, in a scene that is shown rather than implied. A group fight counts once, and a film, its novelisation and its comic adaptation count once between them. Legends is out entirely, which removes one opponent, Galen Marek.

It is worth saying why published numbers differ, because they are all defensible. Count only what is on screen and you get four duels across three scenes — Mandalore, the arrest, the Senate — because the arrest is two fights in one scene: three masters, then Windu. Add the two comic confrontations, Dathomir and the Works, and the total is six.

That gives six. Widen it to any blade he ignites and you get eight, because Ryloth and the Amaxine station are squad fights rather than duels. Widen it to any Force confrontation and you get eleven, because Luke, Rey and Ezra never see him hold a weapon. And the four matchups with the most search traffic are the four that never happened: Nihilus is four thousand years early, Obi-Wan never crosses blades with him, Dooku is his apprentice, and Plagueis dies in his sleep.

The weapon: one hilt, nineteen centimetres

All six duels use the same design. It is short — 19 cm, where most hilts run 20 to 30 — built from phrik, fitted with an aurodium emitter, and finished in electrum, the gold-toned material the Jedi use to mark a master's weapon. A Sith Lord carrying a Jedi honour finish is camouflage, and it works, because nobody looks twice at a ceremonial object.

Macro photograph of a slim gold-toned saber hilt lying diagonally on dark brushed metal with a faint crimson glow behind
Short, gold, and easy to hide in a sleeve. The finish is the disguise.

There are two of them. One falls out of a window in the office fight; the other is carried to the Senate hours later, which is the only reason duel 5 happens at all. They are close enough in shape that the swap is invisible on screen, and that is the point: a spare nobody notices you drawing.

The hilt in all six duels, unlit and up close. Player not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

Duel 1 — Mandalore: the only time he drew two

19 BBY · Sundari palace, Mandalore · The Clone Wars (TCW) S5E16, "The Lawless"

Maul has built a criminal empire on Mandalore and killed the Duchess to do it. Sidious arrives alone, walks into the throne room, and opens by explaining what Maul got wrong: a rival is a rival, and there is only room for two Sith.

Then he ignites both hilts, the only dual-wield of his life on screen. Savage Opress, larger, angrier and holding a double-ended blade, dies in the exchange. Maul is disarmed, thrown around his own throne room and kept alive on purpose, tortured with lightning while Sidious explains that killing him would be a kindness. Two hilts for two claimants, and one of them leaves. The full breakdown of Mandalore covers both sides, including the Darksaber Maul picks up mid-fight.

Two hilts and a coupler in one case: the configuration that makes Maul's side of this duel possible. Player not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

89Sabers Darth Maul double-ended staff hilt

The hilt on his side of this fight

89Sabers Maul

Proffieboard V3.9 · $550 for one hilt, $850 for both halves and the coupler

See the Maul staff

Duel 2 — Dathomir: the borrowed body

19 BBY · Dathomir · Son of Dathomir #4 (2014)

The least-known duel and the strangest. Mother Talzin is not a Sith and does not fight like one: she takes Dooku's body, walks it into the confrontation, and opens with his curved-hilt blade before shedding the disguise and fighting with a green blade of her own making. Sidious is not alone — Dooku and Grievous are both in the room — and this is the only fight in the six where his own saber is the side instrument. What kills Talzin is a convergence rather than a duelist's win, which is why the weapon detail lives in the curved-hilt story.

One more hilt belongs to this scene. Talzin is the only opponent on this list who is neither Sith nor Jedi, and her blade is the only one here that is not a saber in the ordinary sense — which is exactly why the hilt is worth a look: a Nightsister design, not another Jedi pattern with different paint.

Talzin neopixel saber hilt with Nightsister styling

The Nightsister hilt from this scene

Talzin Neopixel Saber

Xenopixel · the Nightsister hilt, not a Jedi pattern · $450

See the Talzin saber

Duel 3 — The office: three deaths in four seconds

19 BBY · the Chancellor's office, Coruscant · Revenge of the Sith (ROTS)

Four masters walk into the Chancellor's office to arrest him. Sidious is standing behind the desk with his hands empty, and then he is not. The hilt comes out of a sleeve, and by the time Windu has his guard up, Kolar, Tiin and Fisto are on the floor.

The blade colours get written wrong constantly. Kolar carries blue in the film and green in every earlier source, including Attack of the Clones (AOTC); the switch was a late production decision, and the novelisation and comic adaptation still describe green. Tiin and Fisto are green on screen. That mismatch is a production artifact, not a lore point. What matters is the shape of the scene: this is the only time in canon he cuts through opponents who are not his equal, and the speed is the entire message.

Of the three masters who die in the first second, only one has a hilt in the lineup. Kolar and Tiin survive on this page as blade colours in the table; Fisto has a build of his own, and at $255 it is the least expensive hilt linked anywhere on this page.

CCSabers' own assembly walkthrough for this hilt. Player not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

Kit Fisto saber hilt in silver and black

The one master who gets a replica

Kit Fisto RGB/Neopixel Saber

RGB, Xenopixel or Proffieboard V2.2 · 32 or 36 inch · from $255

See the Kit Fisto saber

Duel 4 — Windu: the one he lost

19 BBY · the same office, seconds later · ROTS

Windu fights Vaapad, the form built to take a dark side opponent's aggression and send it back, and against Sidious it works exactly as designed. The exchange goes to the window, Sidious is kicked in the face, and the hilt leaves his hand and falls into the Coruscant traffic below.

Then he is on the floor with a purple blade at his throat, and the most powerful Sith alive is out of options. Anakin arrives, chooses badly, and the fight reverses — but the reversal is a rescue, not a comeback. On blades this is a loss, and the creator said so: Windu won the swordfight, and the helplessness afterwards is a performance for the boy in the doorway. The Windu duel, step by step follows that hilt out the window.

The purple blade and belt-wheel hilt that beat him on the window ledge. Player not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

Mace Windu V2 purple-blade saber hilt

The hilt that won the swordfight

Mace Windu V2

S-RGB to Proffieboard V2.2 · belt-wheel hilt · $405 to $595

See the Windu saber

Duel 5 — The Senate: the backup

19 BBY, the same night · Galactic Senate rotunda, Coruscant · ROTS

Yoda comes to the rotunda to kill him and gets closer than anyone else ever does. On blades it is the most even of the six — Ataru and a short blade against Juyo and reach — and it is also the fight where the spare earns its keep. Without a second weapon in reserve, there is no duel 5 at all.

The fight is decided after the blades, which is where the scene gets misread. Sidious changes the arena: the pod rises, the chamber becomes a vertical drop, and a sword fight turns into a survival problem. Yoda leaves alive, and he leaves without the Emperor. The Senate duel in full covers why the spare decided the shape of it.

The short hilt from the rotunda, built to a body about two feet tall. Player not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

89Sabers Yoda compact shoto hilt

The hilt from the rotunda

89Sabers Yoda

Proffieboard V3.9 · 175 mm body · 60 cm blade · $550

See the Yoda saber

Duel 6 — The Works: a lesson with a blade

Early Empire · The Works, Coruscant · Star Wars (2020) #25, "The Lesson"

The last duel happens after the Empire exists, in an industrial district on Coruscant, and it is not a fight. Vader has been using a curved-hilt blade taken from a Jedi he hunted; Sidious takes it off him in seconds, disarms him twice, and then explains the point: the blade was never what made a Sith dangerous.

It is the only duel with a teaching purpose, and the hinge of the whole list. The apprentice is being corrected for fighting like a Jedi — leading with the weapon — and the correction is delivered by removing the weapon. The Lesson covers the scene and the mirrored lesson Obi-Wan gives Anakin in the same issue.

CCSabers' own review of the Vader EP3 hilt: the one from this era, not the curved trophy in the scene. Player not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

89Sabers Darth Vader Episode III saber hilt

The hilt from this era, not the trophy

89Sabers Vader EP3

Neopixel · his own hilt, not the curved blade in the scene · $550

See the Vader EP3

The three he never drew

Three confrontations that people count as duels and should not. In all three he is armed, capable, and does not reach for a weapon.

An open empty hand held out in darkness with faint crimson electrical arcs curling between the fingers
The hand that never closed on a hilt in the last three confrontations of his life.

Luke, on the second Death Star. He says he is unarmed, and he is telling the truth. What he brings to that room is a fleet, a shield, an apprentice and a chair; a blade would have killed the candidate. Why he never drew on Luke is the long version.

Rey, on Exegol. The opposite choice, and the only confrontation on this list where he commits everything: lightning at a scale nothing else in canon matches. It is also the only one where the opponent is family. Rey is his granddaughter, which is why he wants her alive rather than dead, and why the offer he makes is an inheritance rather than an apprenticeship.

The two blades that end him are not hers. She is carrying Anakin's rebuilt saber and Leia's, a Skywalker blade and an Organa one, and the deflection is two inheritances turned back on him at once. Her own hilt — the yellow blade she builds afterwards — is the one in the lineup, not the pair she borrows here.

Ezra, in the World Between Worlds. No body, no blade, a projection and lightning across a doorway that closes. It is the clearest statement of the pattern: by the end, his instrument is presence.

The green hilt he built, carried into the throne room, and threw away. Player not loading? Watch it on YouTube.

The pattern: fewer blades, more control

An empty circular senate chamber seen from above with concentric platforms and one abandoned pod in the centre
The room where the blade stopped being the answer, and the career that followed.

Line the six up and the trajectory is not a decline in skill. It is a change in method. The early fights are the ones he does himself, because the opponent is a peer and there is nobody else to send. Every later confrontation has a substitute: a fleet at Endor, an apprentice in the throne room, a ritual on Exegol, a projection instead of a body.

Which reframes the Windu loss. The one time he is beaten blade to blade is also the last time he treats a fight as something he has to win personally. Everything after it is arranged so somebody else is holding the weapon when the decisive moment arrives.

Every blade in one table

Both sides, with the detail that usually gets lost: colour, form, and what the weapon actually was.

Duel Opponent's blade His blade What decided it
Mandalore Maul: single red, then the Darksaber. Savage: double-ended red Two, the only dual-wield Blade count, and the choice to leave one alive
Dathomir Dooku's curved hilt, then a green blade of Talzin's making One Three attackers instead of one
The office Blue and two greens, standard Jedi issue One, from a sleeve Surprise, and four masters expecting a surrender
Windu Purple, electrum hilt, Vaapad The same hilt, then lost A form built to answer his aggression
The Senate Green, short blade, Ataru The backup, near-identical The arena, not the blades
The Works Red curved hilt, taken from a dead Jedi The remaining hilt Experience, and a lesson he wanted to deliver

Nobody wins on reach. The only opponent who beats him uses a form designed around his own tendencies, and the only one who matches him uses a blade built for a body half his height.

The blades from these duels

Six duels, one recurring hilt, five opponent weapons worth knowing. The two Sidious replicas cover every fight on this page.

Opponent weapon Duel Replica
Yoda's short blade The Senate 89Sabers Yoda · Yoda RGB/Neopixel
Savage's double-ended red Mandalore Savage Opress
The Darksaber Mandalore Darksaber V2
Talzin's green blade Dathomir Talzin Neopixel Saber
Kit Fisto's green blade The office Kit Fisto RGB/Neopixel Saber
Dooku's curved hilt Dathomir Curved-hilt guide
Vader's blade The Works 89Sabers Vader EP3

One honest note. The hilt Vader actually carries in duel 6 is a curved one taken from a Jedi he killed, and no replica of it exists here; the Vader EP3 listed above is his own hilt from the same era, not the prop in that scene.

Sidious crystal-version saber hilt with gold-toned details

The blade in all six duels

89Sabers Sidious Crystal Ver.

Proffieboard V3.9 · crystal chamber · 19 cm body · $685

See the Sidious Crystal Ver.

Where to go next

If you came for one fight, each duel above links to its own deep dive, and those cover both sides of the weapon in detail. If you came for how strong he is, that is a different argument — the Sith ranking handles it without pretending the duels settle it.

The greatest duels in the saga, ranked puts all six in a wider field, and Jedi vs Sith is the doctrine underneath the pattern: why a Sith who needs a blade has already lost the argument.

Frequently asked questions

How many duels did Darth Sidious fight?

Six in canon, counting only fights where he ignites a blade against an armed opponent: Mandalore, Dathomir, his office, Mace Windu, Yoda, and Vader at the Works. Two further blade battles, on Ryloth and at the Amaxine station, are squad fights rather than duels.

Did Darth Sidious ever lose a duel?

Once, to Mace Windu, who disarmed him with a kick and had a blade at his throat before Anakin intervened. The creator's account confirms the disarming was real and that the helplessness afterwards was a performance for Anakin.

Did Darth Sidious use two sabers?

Once, against Maul and Savage Opress on Mandalore. He owns a pair of near-identical hilts, but every other duel on this page is fought with one.

Did Sidious fight Obi-Wan Kenobi?

No. They are in the same building on the Republic's last day and never cross blades. Any article describing a duel between them is describing a hypothetical.

Did Sidious fight Darth Nihilus?

No. Nihilus is an Old Republic Sith from roughly four thousand years earlier. They never share a scene or an era, so there is no encounter to write about.

Did Sidious fight Darth Plagueis?

No. Plagueis is his master, and Sidious kills him in his sleep. The murder is the point, and a duel would have weakened it.

Did Sidious fight Luke Skywalker?

Not with a blade. In the throne room he says he is unarmed and attacks with lightning after Luke refuses to fight. Legends has a blade duel with Luke in Dark Empire, a different continuity.

What saber did Darth Sidious use?

A pair of short hilts, 19 cm each, built from phrik with an aurodium emitter and an electrum finish, carrying red blades from corrupted crystals. One falls out of a window in the office fight; the other is used against Yoda hours later.

Why did he stop using a blade after the prequels?

Because the fights stopped being his to win. Every later confrontation has a substitute — a fleet, an apprentice, a ritual, a projection — and the blade only helps when he is the one who has to do the work.

Which of these sabers can I buy?

The 89Sabers Sidious Crystal Ver. and the Palpatine RGB/Neopixel cover every duel here. Opponent weapons have their own replicas: 89Sabers Maul, Mace Windu V2, 89Sabers Yoda, Savage Opress, the Darksaber V2, the Kit Fisto saber and the Talzin saber. All are character-inspired replicas, not licensed props.

One hilt, six fights

The short electrum hilt that appears in every duel on this page, built as a handled replica.

Shop the Sidious Crystal Ver.

Follow CCSabers

Instagram TikTok YouTube Facebook X

Sources

  1. The works themselves. Revenge of the Sith (2005) for the office and the Senate; The Clone Wars S5E16, "The Lawless", for Mandalore; Son of Dathomir #4 (2014) for Dathomir; Star Wars (2020) #25, "The Lesson", for the Works. These are the primary sources; everything below is a check on them.
  2. StarWars.com Databank: Palpatine's lightsaber — a pair built of phrik, auordium and electrum, carried two-handed against Maul and Savage Opress on Mandalore, then used against the Jedi on Coruscant and against Yoda. One page covers most of the weapon claims above.
  3. StarWars.com Databank: Agen Kolar — names the arrest party (Kolar, Saesee Tiin, Kit Fisto) and the crimson blade that killed them.
  4. StarWars.com Databank: Yoda — he failed to kill the Chancellor and went into exile on Dagobah. The Senate result in one line.
  5. StarWars.com Databank: Rey — granddaughter of Emperor Palpatine, hidden on Jakku.
  6. StarWars.com Databank: Savage Opress — died when Sidious confronted the two Sith on Mandalore.
  7. StarWars.com Databank: Darth Maul's lightsaber — two hilts joined end-to-end, and Maul keeping the working half afterwards.
  8. Named but not linked, on purpose. The 19 cm hilt length is Wookieepedia's, and the site blocks automated requests, so search its "Darth Sidious' lightsabers" entry rather than trust a link here. The claim that Windu overpowers Palpatine and the weakness afterwards is feigned comes from the director's commentary, which has no public transcript.
  9. CCSabers product listings — hilt dimensions, board tiers and prices for the replicas named above.

Questions? Contact us!

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.